|
|
While
there's a clear leader in the firewall software
field, anti-virus software comes down
to personal preference. McAfee and Norton each
offer
solid
products with frequently updated virus definitions.
To help you decide which software fits you best,
I've collected independent reviews from Amazon.com
(their rating is based on user feedback), ZDNet,
and PC
Magazine. Click on the link under 'Reviewer' to
see each review. |
McAfee
VirusScan 8.0 Home Edition
|
 |
|
|
|
McAfee
VirusScan 8.0 protects your PC against
a wide range of viruses, Trojan horses, and
other rogue programs. With so many viruses
being transmitted by e-mail, you absolutely
need an antivirus program to protect your PC
and, more importantly, your data.
McAfee
VirusScan 8.0 installs easily from the
CD-ROM and immediately checks your PC for
any viruses that may already have infected
it. As soon as you connect to the Internet it downloads the
latest updates to ensure you are up-to-date
with all the newest virus signatures.
To enable
it to work effectively, McAfee VirusScan 8.0 operates on many levels.
The new Hostile Activity Watch Kernel
(HAWK)
constantly monitors your PC for viruslike
activity and integrates well with many
different e-mail
clients. The VShield feature runs constantly
in the background, checking files as
you open them. Even if you choose to disable
VShield,
the program still protects Microsoft
Office files by checking them before you open
them.
Another
common way hackers infect PCs is
by using scripts in e-mails. McAfee
VirusScan 8.0 works well here, too, by looking
for suspicious
behavior in scripts such as those trying
to open, write, or delete files. Anything
suspect
is stopped immediately.
For
users running Win 98, 98 SE, and Me only there is
a Safe & Sound
function that makes copies of your documents
and keeps them safe in case they get damaged
by data corruption or virus activity. Note
that this does not work on Windows 2000
and XP.
Some
of the latest viruses can stop antivirus
programs from working properly
once they have infected a machine. If you suspect
this has
occurred, you can boot your PC
directly from the McAfee VirusScan 8.0 installation
CD-ROM,
ensuring a clean environment for
it to work in. You can also create a boot floppy
to
do the same thing.
Like
the other products in
McAfee's security range, McAfee
VirusScan 8.0 uses Instant Updater, which
constantly checks
for product updates and automatically
downloads these when you are online.
Of course, any antivirus product is only as good
as its ability to stop
viruses from infecting your system.
Happily, McAfee VirusScan 8.0 has been
given a 100% rating by Virus Bulletin (although
this assumes you do keep your product
up-to-date with
Instant Updater).
McAfee
VirusScan 8.0 is a worthy
update, and existing users
will appreciate the improved security this
release offers.
Iain
Laskey, Amazon.co.uk
Close
Review
Go
to Site
Like
its arch-rival Norton AntiVirus (NAV) 2003,
McAfee VirusScan 8.0 automatically downloads
up-to-date virus definitions from the Internet;
provides a cogent, lucid interface that's
quick to navigate; squashes malicious scripts,
worms, viruses, and other digital miscreants;
and is reasonably priced. Unlike NAV 2003,
VirusScan 7.0 has superior technical support and
faster scanning times, and it comes with
a firewall -- essential for anyone with
an always-on DSL or cable Internet connection.
Although it's a tad less slick-looking
than NAV 2003, VirusScan 7.0 is a fine
first-time anti-virus choice for any Windows
user.
Current
VirusScan users who use Outlook Express or Eudora will want the
new features for those applications and should upgrade, while current
Outlook users should pass for now. Choosing between NAV 2003 and
VirusScan 7.0? No need to switch if you already run NAV, but if
you're picking for the first time, go with VirusScan.
Installation & Interface
First-time
installation is quick: load the CD and
click the Next button a few times, and
within minutes you're done. But if you're
upgrading from a previous version of VirusScan,
you must uninstall your old copy before
loading version 7.0, which is a major hassle.
You’ll also need to reconfigure your customised
settings -- preset scan times, firewall
configuration and so on -- because version
7.0 can't inherit them.
Like
Norton AntiVirus 2003, VirusScan 7.0 fully
automates its virus-definition downloads
-- you won't need to install these yourself.
Version 7.0 also includes a complimentary
one-year subscription to McAfee's virus-definition
service.
Unlike
NAV 2003, which automatically deletes viruses
once it intercepts them, VirusScan 7.0's
default setting posts a warning dialogue
asking whether you'd like to delete, clean
or quarantine the infected file, which
gives you more control over the process.
However, VirusScan 7.0 users who prefer
Norton's ‘don't bother the user’ method
can change this setting by entering the
Advanced Options dialogue and choosing
either the Clean or Delete (infected files)
menu item.
VirusScan
7.0's interface, with its browser-like
Back, Forward and Home buttons, is pretty
much unchanged from version 6.0, with the
exception of a new feature that allows
you to schedule scans of individual folders.
For example, you can schedule it to check
your always-changing My Documents folder
to provide you with a degree of control
that version 6.0 didn't offer.
Features
Under
the surface, McAfee's Hostile Activity
Watch Kernel (HAWK) detects unfriendly
viruses, such as mass-mailer worms. This
time around, HAWK supports SMTP-based email
clients, such as Microsoft Outlook Express
and Eudora, in addition to Outlook, so
if your email program tries to send a message
to more than 60 percent of your address
book, HAWK will alert you. However, like
NAV 2003, VirusScan 7.0 offers only limited
protection for AOL email users, no thanks
to AOL's proprietary email format.
VirusScan's
VShield in-memory scanner monitors active
scripts for potential trouble from Visual
Basic and JavaScript and also scans file
transfers between your handheld and your
PC. And like NAV 2003, VirusScan 7.0 now
examines file downloads from the popular
instant-messenger applications of Yahoo,
AOL and Microsoft.
But
here's the clincher: version 7.0, like
its predecessor, includes McAfee Firewall
to prevent unauthorised access to Internet-connected
PCs, which is especially important for
those machines with always-on broadband
connections. The firewall is unchanged
since the last version, except that it
now automatically allows desktop applications
such as Internet Explorer, AOL and Music
Maker to access the Internet.
Performance
In
ZDNet Labs' performance tests, VirusScan
7.0 beat NAV 2003 soundly in scanning speed
(the amount of time it takes to search
your PC for viruses), while both anti-virus
programs made a similarly minimal impact
on overall PC performance. To measure VirusScan
7.0's impact on system performance, we
used BAPCo's SysMark2002, an industry-standard
benchmark. The Internet Content Creation
portion of SysMark measures a desktop's
performance running off-the-shelf applications
such as Adobe’s Photoshop, Microsoft Windows
Media Encoder, and Macromedia’s Dreamweaver.
(We did not run the Office Productivity
portion of the benchmark because it incorporates
McAfee VirusScan 5.13.)
Our
test system was a Compaq Evo W4000, running
Windows XP Professional, with a 2.4GHz
Pentium 4 processor and 512MB of DDR RAM.
With VirusScan 7.0 running, our test system
scored a 97 -- a 3 percent reduction in
overall system speed, which is reasonable
and wouldn't be noticed by most users.
In comparison, Norton AntiVirus 2003 scored
a 95, or a 5 percent reduction in system
speed. (An Internet Content Creation score
of 100 represents the performance of our
test system without any extraneous software
running). In a test of scanning speed,
VirusScan 7.0 took an average of 1.7 minutes
to scan a 1GB directory, beating NAV 2003,
which averaged 3.1 minutes.
To
determine whether VirusScan effectively
blocks viruses, we examined its past performance
in tests conducted by independent antivirus-testing
laboratories. In the latest Virus Bulletin
tests, VirusScan 6.0 earned the coveted
VB 100 percent rating only once in the
three most recent Windows tests, compared
to Norton AntiVirus 2003, which won all
of the last three Windows tests. However,
VirusScan has performed as well as Norton
in live virus tests conducted by AV-Test.org.
Previous versions of VirusScan have also
been certified by the independent antivirus-testing
laboratories at West Coast Checkmark and
ICSA Labs.
Technical
support
VirusScan
8.0's interface includes links to a respectable
collection of FAQs and troubleshooting
tips on McAfee's Web site. We were pleased
with McAfee's Web-based technical 24/7
chat with a technical support rep, too.
In our tests, the reps were knowledgeable
and helped us repair a scanning glitch.
If
you're choosing an anti-virus package for
the first time, McAfee VirusScan 8.0 is
a fine choice. It's a hard-working, virus-crushing
crusader that delivers solid value for
money. Existing VirusScan users who run
Outlook Express or Eudora should upgrade,
but Outlook users will find the overall
enhancements to be marginal.
Jeff
Bertolucci
Close
Review
Go to Site
With firewall
and PDA protection, McAfee VirusScan Home Edition 8.0 ably secures
your system against
multiple threats. VirusScan is a good deal if you
know what you're doing. But its plethora of configuration options can leave
less experienced users perplexed by tough decisions about suspicious files.
VirusScan's improved HAWK (Hostile Activity Watch Kernel) looks for behavior
redolent of mass-mailing worms, malicious scripts, attachments with double
extensions, and even rapid forwarding of e-mails in succession. It also scans
files transferred to and from a PDA and Microsoft Office documents.
The revamped interface is now better suited to beginners but not as streamlined
as that of Norton AntiVirus (NAV). It takes some digging to get to advanced
settings, but home users shouldn't need to change the defaults, which scan
all files. In case you need to change settings, VirusScan, like NOD32, allows
detailed control over scanning and actions taken when viruses are detected.
As with Panda Antivirus and PC-cillin, generic heuristics are turned on by
default, but you have to activate macro and script heuristics manually. As
with NAV, the initial definition file is big (over 4MB on our tests), but regular
updates are small. You have to register VirusScan to receive updates. (By contrast,
NAV doesn't require registration.) As a bonus, VirusScan's Instant Updater
displays outbreak alerts.
When VirusScan detects
a virus, it asks you to choose an appropriate responseputting
undue responsibility on inexperienced users. For instance, if it detects an
infected file within a ZIP file and you choose Delete, VirusScan deletes the
entire ZIP, not just the infected file. You can change the default actions
as you see fit. In-depth e-mail alerts, similar to those of NOD32, describe
the detected virus, and auto-replies can be directed to the sender of an infected
e-mail.
VirusScan offers comprehensive control over scheduled scans, even letting
you choose a window of time so that scans won't always begin at the same time.
Configurable logs show minute details of each scan, including engine version
and settings.
As with NAV, you're encouraged to seek help for basic questions on McAfee's
Web site via FAQs, user forums, and live chat. Paid phone support starts at
a steep $39 per incident or $2.95 per minute. A downloadable Stinger tool repairs
hidden damage caused by viruses, and a slick McAfee Security Center applet
can check the overall security of your PC, including the status of virus definitions
(for any popular AV product, not just VirusScan) and the existence of firewalls
and spam filters.
With a firewall included at no extra charge, VirusScan offers bang for the
buck, but it's best suited to experienced users who relish adjusting advanced
settings.
Greg Alwang
Close
Review
Go to Site
|
|
Norton
AntiVirus 2004 Home Version
|
 |
|
|
|
From
the Manufacturer
*Awarded PC Magazine's Editors' Choice Award in November 2003.*
Symantec’s
Norton AntiVirus 2004 now comes with
expanded detection of both known and
emerging threats. Norton AntiVirus
detects and removes viruses, worms,
and Trojan horses automatically--without
interrupting your work.
It
works in the background 24 hours a
day to protect email messages, instant
message attachments, Internet downloads,
and other files. Now it can also detect
viruses in compressed file archives
before you open them, reducing the
risk of infecting your computer. Symantec’s
exclusive LiveUpdate technology automatically
checks for new virus protection updates
on a regular schedule to keep the program
up to date against the latest threats.
It now even alerts you when your virus
protection is getting outdated.
Norton
AntiVirus also defends your PC against
emerging threats. Script Blocking intercepts
fast-moving script-based viruses such
as "ILoveYou" and "Anna
Kournikova," and Worm Blocking
stops worms from using your outgoing
email messages to infect other computers.
The expanded threat detection in Norton
AntiVirus 2004 alerts you to the presence
of spyware, keystroke loggers, and
similar programs that can steal personal
information and leave your PC vulnerable
to other attacks. Stop viruses and
protect your PC with award-winning
Norton AntiVirus. Small office packs
for five or 10 users are also available.
Features:
• Expanded
threat detection alerts you to certain
non-virus threats such as spyware and
keystroke logging programs.
• Scans compressed file archives before you open them and risk infecting your
computer. (Not available on Windows Me/98.)
• Includes product activation procedure to ensure authenticity.
• Automatically removes viruses, worms, and Trojan horses.
• Scans and cleans both incoming and outgoing email messages.
• Detects and blocks viruses in instant message attachments.
• Downloads new virus protection updates automatically to protect against new
threats.*
• Worm Blocking detects worms such as "Nimda" in outgoing mail.
• Script Blocking defends against fast-moving, script-based viruses such as "ILoveYou" and "Anna
Kournikova."
• Worm Blocking and Script Blocking can detect new threats even before virus
protection updates are created for them.
*12
months of virus protection updates
included with purchase of Norton AntiVirus
2004; annual subscriptions available
online for subsequent updates per computer.
Close
Review
Go
to Site
Norton
AntiVirus (NAV) 2004 debuts with
a promising pedigree. Previous versions
have consistently led the anti-virus
pack in security innovations, being
the first, for example, to scan instant-messaging
attachments as well as inbound and
outbound email. The program routinely
receives high marks from independent
anti-virus testing laboratories.
Its interface is easy for beginners
to navigate, yet it offers advanced
users plenty of scanning options.
The 2004 version continues the traditions
(including some we don't like, namely
the fee-based phone support), but
it adds an imperfect anti-spyware
feature. NAV 2004 is a solid program
for first-time anti-virus users,
but its half-hearted enhancements
make it a questionable £29.99 (inc.
VAT) upgrade for existing users.
Setup & interface
Norton
AntiVirus 2004 offers the option
of a pre-installation virus scan,
an added protection measure not matched
by its leading competitor, McAfee’s
VirusScan 8.0. This procedure adds
a lot of time to the setup process,
however -- 30 minutes on our test
PC. Users with time constraints may
wish to bypass it (NAV does an automatic
postinstall, scan, too).
The
program froze during our first install
attempt, but it ran perfectly once
we rebooted. NAV 2004 supports Windows
98 through XP and requires a slightly
larger amount of drive space than
previous versions -- from 85MB to
125MB, depending on the OS version.
After
setup is completed, NAV connects
automatically to Symantec's Web server
to download the latest virus definitions.
NAV 2004 users get a year of free
definitions, after which the annual
fee is £13.81. Symantec has also
added an activation process similar
to that used by Microsoft in Windows
XP, although we found this to be
a painless extra step.
NAV
2004's well-designed interface changes
little from its predecessor's. The
main screen presents a snapshot of
your PC's security, with red or yellow
icons marking items that need attention,
such as outdated virus definitions.
Default settings provide strong security
by automatically deleting viruses
and scanning compressed ZIP files,
as well as stopping spyware and Trojans
from infecting your PC. Popular options,
such as scheduling automatic scans,
are easily accessible.
Features
NAV
2004 adds two major capabilities.
First is its enhanced detection of
compressed files. Previous versions
of NAV detected viruses embedded
in ZIP and other compressed formats
during manual scans. NAV 2004's real-time
scanner finds and deletes these hidden
viruses on the fly -- as they are
being downloaded, for example --
adding another layer of protection.
NAV
2004's second new feature is the
ability to detect and destroy spyware,
adware and hacking tools that may
be lurking on your hard drive. NAV
2004 is the first anti-virus application
to include this feature. However,
the free standalone utilities, such
as Lavasoft's Ad-aware and PepiMK’s Spybot
Search & Destroy, ferret out
these same annoyances much better.
For example, in our tests, NAV 2004
failed to find a malware component
uncovered by Ad-aware 6.0 in a follow-up
scan (we ran Ad-aware immediately
after the completion of a Norton
system scan).
Performance
In
our tests, NAV 2004 caused a 4 percent
drag on our test system's performance.
McAfee VirusScan 8.0, on the other
hand, produced no perceptible drag.
But NAV 2004 scanned our 1GB drive
much faster than McAfee did. Here
are our test results in full:
| Norton
AntiVirus 2004 v Mcafee VirusScan
8.0 |
|
|
Test
system
|
Norton
AntiVirus 2004
|
McAfee
VirusScan 8.0
|
|
| SysMark2002
Internet-content-creation (ICC) score |
233 |
223 |
234 |
| Normalised
score |
100 |
96 |
100 |
| Percentage
degradation |
n/a |
4 |
0 |
| Average
boot time (s) |
40.8 |
52.72 |
48.38 |
| Scan
1GB directory; average scan time (m) |
n/a |
3.59 |
4.75 |
|
Norton
AntiVirus has been tested on Windows
systems six times since 2000 by the
independent testing organisation
VirusBulletin and earned its coveted
VB 100 percent title each time. By
comparison, McAfee's VirusScan has
been tested and earned a VB 100 percent
title only once. However, it's hard
to draw any meaningful conclusions
from such limited data. Previous
versions of Norton AntiVirus have
also been certified by the independent
anti-virus testing laboratories at
West Coast Checkmark, ICSA Labs and
AV-test.org.
Service & support
Like
McAfee, unfortunately, Symantec charges
for its live technical support via
phone -- £18 per incident. We tried
the free alternative: email. The
form was hard to locate, but representatives
were responsive, answering within
24 to 48 hours. Unfortunately, Norton
does not offer technical support
via online chat, a feature that McAfee
offers (with mixed results) for its
VirusScan customers. The Automated
Support Assistant, another feature
accessible via the support site,
is a convenient way to download product
upgrades and keep your copy of NAV
2004 up-to-date. Symantec's free
online knowledge base is a helpful
do-it-yourself resource.
Jeff
Bertolucci
Close
Review
Go to Site
With
Norton AntiVirus 2004 (NAV), Symantec
adds new touches to a familiar face,
keeping NAV atop our A-list. It can
now scan your system for installation-stopping
viruses before installation, instead
of using the old DOS boot CD and
a slow command line scanner. It also
prescans at setup and scans within
ZIP and other archive files by default.
Keeping
up with the times, NAV now finds
and removes spyware, adware, and
dialers. Also new is protection for
instant messageborne threats
in Yahoo! Messenger, MSN/ Windows
Messenger, and AIM. NAV performs
automatic updates by default, and
you get a systemwide warning when
your virus pattern files are out
of date.
Installation
now includes a product-activation
scheme that the company hopes will
keep illegal copying of its software
under control. This requires you
to connect with a server at Symantec
to get an activation code to use
NAV. Activation is anonymous, and
registration is not required. You
can reinstall as many times as you
like on the same machine, and you
have the flexibility to upgrade to
a newer machine without buying a
new copy.
Spyware,
adware, and dialers, while not technically
viruses, are threats to your privacy
and finances. Like McAfee VirusScan
8.0, NAV now scans and removes these
threats. In our testing, NAV found
most of our adware, though it missed
some spyware and dialers and had
difficulty removing others. Symantec
claims that NAV will stop incoming
spyware and adware received via instant
messaging or e-mail but not from
Web sites.
This
version of NAV has improved default
settings. The installation wizard
walks you through the options, which
include automatic updates, a full
initial system scan, weekly system
scans, and real-time scanning of
compressed files. The status screen
shows green, yellow, or red icons
to indicate your protection level.
In previous versions, if you let
your updates lag, only the Update
icon turns yellow or red. In NAV
2004, if you bypass an update, the
program displays yellow and red icons
across the board, indicating that
auto-protection is out of gas.
With
a 6.4 percent slowdown, NAV came
in last on our performance degradation
tests, though the hit wasn't significantly
worse than VirusScan's 5.9 percent.
We think this minor performance impact
is a good trade-off for the protection
you get. As with VirusScan, NAV has
conservative defaults that provide
excellent protection. With better
defaults and easy updates, Norton
AntiVirus once again gets our Editors'
Choice nod.
Jay
Munro
Close
Review
Go to Site
|
|
|
|